Problem Positions and Nineteen Instances in the Smog Control Case Los Angeles County 1943-1976
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.36285/tm.115Abstract
This is the second of two papers which examines the aggregation dynamics in a case study of smog control in Los Angeles County in 1943-1976. First, it elaborates problem positions of some typical interested and affected parties in the case study. Second, it reworks the history of air pollution control in Los Angeles County into a foundation for further research.
References
Ed Ainsworth, Divided Opinions on Smog Control Complicate Issue, The Los Angeles Times (1946), no. November 5, pp. 11 & 22.
Ed Ainsworth, Fight to Banish Smog, Bring Sun Back to City Pressed, The Los Angeles Times (1946), no. October 13, pp. 1 & 7.
Ed Ainsworth, Smog Hunted by Expert From Law Libraries to City’s Laboratories, The Los Angeles Times (1946), no. December 21, pp. 1 & 3.
Ed Ainsworth, Thirteen Suits to Be Filed in Smog Fight, The Los Angeles Times (1946), no. October 15, pp. 1 & 2.
Ed Ainsworth, ‘TIMES’ BRINGING SMOG EXPERT HERE, The Los Angeles Times (1946), no. December 1, p. 1.
Ed Ainsworth, Smog Controller McCabe Arrives to Assume Duties, The Los Angeles Times (1947), no. October 2, p. 15.
Ed Ainsworth, Supervisors Pick Chief for Smog Fight, The Los Angeles Times (1947), no. August 27, p. 1.
Ed Ainsworth, CAUSE OF SMOG’S EYE SMARTING TOLD, The Los Angeles Times (1949), no. February 26, pp. 1 & 12.
Joseph Alsop, Is McCarthy Kidding About Smog Control?, Pasadena Independent (1960), no. 26 July, p. 7.
Associated Press, Industrialists Enter Defenses, The San Bernardino County Sun (1950), no. February 25, p. 2.
Associated Press, Rain to End Smog Attack, The Spokesman-Review (1958), no. November 27, p. 17, Spokane, Washington.
Asa Atwater, Toxic Fumes Believed Cause of 19 Deaths; Hundreds Stricken, The Pittsburgh Press (1948), no. November 1, pp. 1 & 2.
Bill Barger, Smog Control Districts Urged at L.A. Meeting, Riverside Daily Press (1953), no. October 26, p. 5.
Bay Area Air Quality Management District, Consulted on January 23, 2024.
J. A. Bergstra, J. Heering, and P. Klint, Module algebra, 37 (1990), no. 2, pp. 335–372.
J.A. Bergstra, A. Ponse, and J.J. van Wamel, Process algebra with backtracking, A Decade of Concurrency Reflections and Perspectives (J.W. de Bakker, W.P. de Roever, and G. Rozenberg, eds.), LNCS, vol. 803, Springer, 1994, pp. 46–91.
Graham Berry, L.A. Smog Control Director Often Is Target For Abuse – Actually He Has Accomplished Much, The San Bernardino County Sun (1954), no. November 7, p. 5.
James Bonner, Arie Jan Haagen-Smit 1900–1977, Biographical Memoirs, National Academy of Sciences, Washington DC, 1989.
California Air Resources Board, page on the history, consulted January 22, 2024.
California Air Resources Board, California’s air basins map, consulted February 19, 2025.
George Caulfield, Bay Area’s Smog Menace Grows as Civic Action Lags, The San Francisco Examiner (1950), no. December 17, pp. 35 & 42.
David Colander, The future of economics: the appropriately educated in pursuit of the knowable, Cambridge Journal of Economics 29 (2005), no. 6, pp. 927–941.
C.P. Corliss, Butadiene Plant to Eliminate Fumes With New Process, The Pasadena Post (1943), no. November 1, p. 5.
Daily Independent Journal, Commuters Of Twin City Area To Form Car Pool, 1954, no. October 1, p. 22.
Daily News, Smog bother? Fill out form, 1944, no. November 10, p. 41.
Daily News, Smoke problem 70 per cent licked, says health bureau, 1945, no. August 17, p. 41.
Daily News, McCabe defends smog control program, 1949, no. February 2, p. 3.
S.H. Dewey, Don’t Breathe the Air: Air Pollution and U.S. Environmental Politics, 1945-1970, Environmental History Series, no. 16, Texas A&M University Press, 2000.
DOGE, home page of The Department of Government Efficiency, consulted February 25, 2025.
John Dreyfuss, VW and Chrysler Pass State Smog Tests, Are OKd for Sale, The Los Angeles Times (1972), no. June 23, p. 3.
Harry G. Frankfurt, On bullshirt, Princeton University Press, 2005.
Friends of Francis H. Packard, Elect FRANCIS H. PACKARD, Valley Times (1956), no. June 4, p. 28.
James T. Gilson, Mayor Backs West Coast Plan in Fight on Air Pollution, The Philadelphia Inquirer (1958), no. December 1, p. 2.
A.J. Haagen-Smit, Chemistry and Physiology of Los Angeles Smog, Industrial and engineering chemistry 44 (1952), no. 6, pp. 1342–1346.
A.J. Haagen-Smit, E.F. Darley, M. Zaitlin, H. Hull, and W. Noble, Investigation on Injury to Plants from Air Pollution in the Los Angeles Area, Plant physiology (Bethesda) 27 (1952), no. 1, pp. 18–34.
Hanson, Sam, Off the Beat. SC County Gives Up Own Smog Program As Regional Effort Starts, Los Gatos Times-Saratoga Observer (1955), no. July 18, pp. 1 & 8.
William Hendricks, All Set If Strike Comes, The San Francisco Examiner (1954), no. September 26, p. 16.
Chip Jacobs and William J. Kelly, Smogtown: The Lung-Burning History of Pollution in Los Angeles, Overlook Press, Woodstock & New York, 2008.
Thomas Jefferson, WHAT VALLEY PEOPLE THINK, Valley Times (1954), no. September 24, p. 14.
Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, Farrar, Straus & Giroux Inc, 2012.
James Krier and Edmund Ursin, Pollution and Policy. A Case Essay on California and Federal Experience with Motor Vehicle Air Pollution 1940 - 1975, University of California Press, 1977.
Basil E. Leever, RUNNING AROUND IN CIVIC CIRCLES, Press-Telegram (1945), no. February 25, p. 2.
Long Beach Press-Telegram, County Fumes Erasure Law Studied for City, 1945, no. January 27, p. 7.
Los Angeles Evening Citizen News, Trial Balloons for Smog, 1946, September 16, p. 3.
Los Angeles Evening Citizen News, City to Merge Smog-Fighting Staff With County’s Setup, 1948, no. January 31, p. 2.
Joseph P. McCarthy, Supervisors Will Oppose APCD Regional Planning, The San Bernardino County Sun (1968), no. July 16, p. 15.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, ANTI-SMOG PROGRAM SUBMITTED. 16 Foothill Cities Study 8-point Recommendations, 1945, no. November 21, p. 9.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, Fumes Law To Be Ready Next Month, 1945, no. May 25, p. 8.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, LOS ANGELES CHAMBER DENIES APATHY. OFFERS, TO AID IN FUMES FIGHT, 1945, no. October 10, p. 19.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, State ‘Anti-Smog’ Law Urged at Meeting, 1945, no. September 26, p. 17.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, Supervisors Adopt Two New Anti-Smog Laws, 1945, no. April 22, p. 11.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, Assemblyman Joins Fight Against Smoke, Fumes, 1946, no. October 6, p. 21.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, County Attacks ‘Smog’ as Former Adviser Says Problem ‘Politics’, 1946, no. April 22, p. 11.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, COUNTY CONDUCTS TEST OF AIR POLLUTION HERE, 1946, no. May 28, p. 11.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, Diesel Truck Driver Cited For Smog, 1946, no. October 30, p. 11.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, BOARD SEEKS TO ABATE SMUDGE EVIL, 1947, no. January 9, p. 13.
Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News, State Chamber Directors Back Anti-Smog Legislation, 1947, no. April 28, p. 11.
Oakland Tribune, Home Owners Protest Smog, 1953, no. October 30, p. 29.
Thad Omohundro, JESSUP FAILS TO OUST FUMES AIDE, Metropolitan Pasadena Star-News (1945), no. January 23, pp. 13 & 15.
Optimist International, consulted February 19 2025.
Pasadena Independent, What people think, 1943, no. October 21, p. 30 & 32.
Pasadena Independent, Citizens Demand Smog End Or Political Housecleaning, 1946, no. October 2, pp. 1 & 18.
Pasadena Independent, Let’s Go, Little Guys!, 1954, no. October 20, pp. 1 & 31.
Pasadena Independent, Auto Industry Perfects Gadget to Eliminate Hydrocarbon 80%, 1955, no. July 28, pp. 1 & 42.
Pasadena Independent, Best Weapon in War Against Smog, 1955, no. June 2, p. 3.
Pasadena Independent, Industry Aid Sought on Smog, 1955, no. October 16, p. 8.
Pasadena Independent, Oil Man Lays Smog to Autos, 1955, no. October 16, p. 8.
Pasadena Independent, Griswold Gloomy on Smog Controls, 1958, no. December 4, p. 2.
Alexis Pedrick and Elisabeth Berry Drago, Fighting Smog in Los Angeles, podcast, episode 232 of Distillations, Science and History Institute, Philadelphia, 26 June 2018, episode 232 of Distillations, Science and History Institute, Philadelphia.
Petaluma Argus-Courier, BAY AREA SMOG DISTRICT FORMED, 1955, no. July 9, p. 1.
Press-Telegram, Canneries Questioned on Odors, 1945, no. October 11, p. 15.
Press-Telegram, Anti-Smog Plans Told, 1946, no. May 24, p. 4.
Press-Telegram, Antifumes Plan Will Be Aired Monday, 1946, no. October 11, p. 11.
Press-Telegram, Antismog Plan Favored by Health Head, 1946, no. October 17, p. 13.
Press-Telegram, City Will Aid Smog War, 1946, no. May 8, p. 9.
Press-Telegram, Ending of Harbor Odor Discussed, 1946, no. November 11, p. 12.
Press-Telegram, Incinerator Bond Issue Vote Ordered, 1946, no. January 22, p. 9.
Press-Telegram, Ordinance to End Smog Voted Here, 1946, no. November 26, p. 9.
Press-Telegram, Pasadena Wants ‘State’ Smog Law, 1946, no. July 20, p. 7.
Press-Telegram, Smog Control Rules Detailed, 1946, no. November 21, p. 24.
Press-Telegram, Tests First Step in Smog Control, 1946, no. May 10, p. 13.
Redlands Daily Facts, Pike Opposes Air Pollution District Merger, 1958, no. 25 January, p. 5.
Redlands Daily Facts, Regional smog control effort planned. Nine county representatives to meet Sept. 28, 1970, no. September 3, p. 3.
Redwood City Tribune, Battle Smog at Home First, Urges Board, 1953, no. November 18, p. 1.
R.E.G.H., The way to clear the skies, Daily News (1949), no. February 2, p. 32.
Herman de Regt and Hans Dooremalen, Het snapgevoel: Hoe de illusie van begrip ons denken gijzelt, Boom, Amsterdam, 2015, In Dutch.
Thomas C. Schelling, Micromotives and Macrobehavior, W.W. Norton & Company Inc., 1978.
Senate and House of Representatives, PUBLIC LAW 159-JULY 14, 1955, consulted February 22, 2025.
Don Shannon, Members of U.S. Smog Committee Announced, The Los Angeles Times (1954), no. December 7, p. 1.
William E. Simpson, Difficulties of the District Attorney, The Los Angeles Times (1946), no. December 9, p. 16.
South Gate Daily Press-Tribune, Air Pollution Control Law to Be Passed Here, 1946, no. December 7, p. 1.
South Gate Daily Press-Tribune, Municipal Group Urges Cities to Cooperate in Smog Control, 1946, no. November 23, p. 1.
South Gate Press, Need Auto Exhaust Control; Car Makers Must Help−−Griswold, 1955, no. July 17, p. 12.
South Pasadena Review, South Pasadena To Join 26 Other County Cities In Passing Uniform Ordinance Against Smog Problem, 1946, no. May 10, p. 1.
South Pasadena Review, Citizens Anti-Smog Committee Endorses Seven Point Program, 1954, no. November 11, p. 11.
South Pasadena Review, BUREAU OF AIR SANITATION IS TO BE FORMED, 1955, no. 21 July, p. 6.
Arthur C. Stern, History of Air Pollution Legislation in the United States, Journal of the Air Pollution Control Association 32 (1982), no. 1, pp. 44–61, PMID: 7033323.
Stockton Evening and Sunday Record, MV Director Raps Costly Smog Devices, 1960, no. 21 July, p. 14.
The Californian, Bay Area Smog Laws Are Urged, 1955, no. March 5, p. 1.
The Colton Courier, County Air Pollution District Formed By Board Of Supervisors, 1956, no. 20 June, p. 1.
The Covina Argus, State C of C Gives Unqualified Okay to Smog Measure, 1947, no. May 9, p. 10.
The Desert Sun, Board Adapts County Air Pollution Control Rules, 1959, no. January 8, p. 6.
The Desert Sun, Chamberlain Joins Jones, McCall in Smog Vote, 1959, no. February 19, p. 16.
The Fresno Bee, Pollution Board Views Smog Device For Cars; Cost Varies, 1960, no. December 20, p. 19.
The Highland Park News-Herald, City council balks at action to abate fumes, 1944, no. September 15, p. 4.
The Highland Park News-Herald, Supervisors authorize district attorney to act in obnoxious fumes case, 1944, no. September 15, p. 4.
The Long Beach Sun, Committee Fight Fume Peril Is Named, 1943, no. October 21, p. 5.
The Los Angeles Times, City Hunting for Source of ‘Gas Attack’, 1943, no. July 27, p. 1.
The Los Angeles Times, HEAVY GAS FUMES IN AIR BLAMED FOR SMARTING EYES, 1943, no. July 10, p. 1.
The Los Angeles Times, Legal Action Hinted Over Plant Fumes, 1943, no. September 23, p. 1.
The Los Angeles Times, RELIEF FROM GAS FUMES PROMISED IN DECEMBER, 1943, no. September 15, p. 23.
The Los Angeles Times, Air Pollution Control Bureau Urged for City, 1944, no. October, 27, p. 13.
The Los Angeles Times, EXPERT SAYS SMOG CAN BE ELIMINATED, 1944, no. November 28, p. 13.
The Los Angeles Times, Law Ordered Drafted to Curb Fumes Nuisance, 1944, no. September 16, p. 3.
The Los Angeles Times, Legion Honors ‘Times’ Writer, 1944, no. January 29, p. 11.
The Los Angeles Times, CITIES PREPARE TO PUSH ANTI-SMOG ENFORCEMENT, 1945, no. September 26, p. 12.
The Los Angeles Times, Expert Arrives to Study Smog Here for ‘Times’, 1946, no. December 9, pp. 1 & 2.
The Los Angeles Times, High School Editors Hear ‘Times’ Speakers, 1946, no. March 13, p. 13.
The Los Angeles Times, How Ainsworth Wrote Epic Novel of California, 1946, no. September 22, p. 25.
The Los Angeles Times, Jeffers to Head Smog Committee, 1946, no. December 20, Part II, pp. 1 & 7.
The Los Angeles Times, Smog Problem Topic on Radio Tonight, 1946, no. December 10, p. 1.
The Los Angeles Times, The Shame of the Smog, 1946, no. 26 September, p. 16.
The Los Angeles Times, We Can Curb the Smog Nuisance, 1946, no. July 20, p. 12.
The Los Angeles Times, Weather Likely to Give Smog Expert Real Show, 1946, no. December 12, pp. 1–2.
The Los Angeles Times, Writer to Address Inglewood Clubs, 1946, no. May 26, p. 3.
The Los Angeles Times, CHAMBER EXPERTS OPEN WAR ON SMOG, 1947, no. March 20, p. 13.
The Los Angeles Times, Governor Signs Anti-Smog Bill, 1947, no. June 11, p. 1.
The Los Angeles Times, Group Executive Outlines Needs in Smog Control, 1947, no. March 13, City News, pp. 11 & 16.
The Los Angeles Times, One Year in the Smog Fight, 1947, no. December 31, p. 16.
The Los Angeles Times, Smog Bill Voted; Goes to Governor, 1947, no. June 3, p. 1.
The Los Angeles Times, Smog Control Wins Victory in Committee, 1947, no. April 30, pp. 1 & 5.
The Los Angeles Times, SMOKE COMMITTEE ASKS FOR LAW WITH TEETH, 1947, no. January 25, p. 4.
The Los Angeles Times, System for Smog Control Unified, 1947, October 15, pp. pp. 1–2.
The Los Angeles Times, The Smog Bill Progresses, 1947, no. May 4, p. 18.
The Los Angeles Times, Let’s Face Facts on Smog, 1948, no. September 16, p. 30.
The Los Angeles Times, No Sidetracking on Smog!, 1948, no. November 23, p. 28.
The Los Angeles Times, ‘Not So,’ Oil Industry Replies to Smog Detectives’ Findings , 1948, no. September 28, p. 23.
The Los Angeles Times, Whittier Yells ‘Secede’ in Trash-Burning Fight, 1948, no. August 22, p. 3.
The Los Angeles Times, Committee Hears Views Presented by Jeffers, 1949, no. February 4, p. 23.
The Los Angeles Times, Report Reveals 40 ‘Villains’ in Smog, 1949, no. October 25, p. 31.
The Los Angeles Times, SMOG’S COMPLEX MAKE-UP STRESSED, 1949, no. December 9, pp. 31 & 38.
The Los Angeles Times, Heavy Gasoline Losses Eyed in War on Smog, 1953, no. April 22, p. 22.
The Los Angeles Times, 4500 Hear Demand for Smog Probe, 1954, pp. 2–4, October 21.
The Los Angeles Times, Air Pollution Can Be Whipped, Larson Says, 1954, no. April 13, p. 14.
The Los Angeles Times, Auto Exhaust, Ozone Get Major Smog Blame, 1954, no. July 29, p. 1.
The Los Angeles Times, AUTO EXPERTS COMING HERE FOR SMOG STUDY, 1954, no. January 8, p. 27.
The Los Angeles Times, IRRITATED, 1954, no. October 15, p. 3.
The Los Angeles Times, Long Smog Fight Seen by Stanford Expert, 1954, no. December 7, p. 13.
The Los Angeles Times, Progress Told on Reducing Exhaust Smog, 1954, no. January 8, p. 27.
The Los Angeles Times, WOMEN PROTEST SMOG, 1954, no. October 21, p. 2.
The Pasadena Post, AN END TO TALK; ACTION NEEDED, 1943, no. September 14, p. 5.
The Pasadena Post, FUMES SUIT HEARING SET FOR NOV. 1, 1943, no. October 22, pp. 5 & 10.
The Pasadena Post, HOLDING OUR HOPE FOR MONDAY, 1943, no. September 17, p. 5.
The Pasadena Post, SPEED ACTION GAS EVIL, 1943, no. September 11, p. 5.
The Pasadena Post, Three Complaints an Hour to Health Department, 1943, no. September 11, p. 5.
The Pomona Progress Bulletin, Fumes and Smoke Committee is Dismissed, 1945, no. January 30, p. 9.
The Pomona Progress Bulletin, Irate Over County Smog Suit Whittier Talks of Secession, 1948, no. August 23, p. 14.
The Pomona Progress Bulletin, AS WE SEE IT .. By One of Us, 1954, no. July 20, p. 4.
The Press Democrat, Anti-Smog Devices On Cars Provided by Bill, 1960, no. March 29, p. 25.
The Register, Smudging Controls Provided, 1950, no. June 29, p. 23.
The Sacramento Bee, State Launches Investigation Of Air Pollution, 1955, no. 6 August, p. 4.
The San Bernardino County Sun, AIR POLLUTION DISTRICT SOUGHT BY 5 COUNTIES, 1957, no. 12 October, p. 13.
The Signal, Free fresh air, 1945, no. February 8, p. 4.
The Southwest Wave, RIP TIDE, 1960, no. 4 August, p. 1.
The Whittier News, CITY NOT TO DISCONTINUE USE OF DUMP, 1948, no. May 18, p. 1.
The Whittier News, City Offers To Help On Incinerator, 1948, no. October 22, p. 1.
The Whittier News, Functions of County Air Pollution Control District Related for News, 1948, no. June 17, p. 9.
The Whittier News, Chief Issues Fire Permit, 1949, no. June 10, p. 9.
Valley Times, Howard Stites Denies Smog In Burbank, 1946, no. October 16, p. 3.
Valley Times, Opposing Sides Admit Smog Suit May Relapse, 1946, no. 19 October, p. 7.
Valley Times, Report On Bus Fumes Enters Service Hearing, 1954, no. January 26, p. 2.
Valley Times, Carpenter Petitions Court for Ballot Spot In Supervisor Race, 1956, no. August 26, pp. 1–2.
Valley Times, BATTLE BEING WON. $100 Million Goes Into Smog Fight, 1958, p. 38, September 9, North Hollywood, California.
Valley Times, MAIN PROBLEM. Autos Still Held Top Air Pollutant, 1958, no. September 9, p. 38.
B. van Vlijmen, Aggregation dynamics: From problems and solutions to a generalized ecology, Transmathematica (2023).
S.F.M. van Vlijmen, Exploration of selected problem and solution types in Los Angeles County smog control 1943-1976, Transmathematica (2025).
Peter Weisser, 18 Stern Bills Propose Curbs On Air, Water Pollution, The Sacramento Bee (1970), no. January 6, p. 7.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Bas van Vlijmen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Authors retain copyright and, if appropriate, performance rights but licence the journal to publish submissions. The lead author confirms that the submission is bound by the CC Attributtion Share Alike 4.0 licence.
